osmarks/documentation
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Releases Wiki Activity

Edit ‘decision_theory/newcombs_paradox’

Browse Source
This commit is contained in:
osmarks 2024-09-22 20:06:44 +00:00 committed by wikimind
parent 78ed60ff92
commit b3284d2599
1 changed files with 10 additions and 2 deletions
Show Stats Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

12
decision_theory/newcombs_paradox.myco
View File

@ -1,3 +1,11 @@
Imagine [[Omega]], a perfectly honest being which is also known to be a historically very accurate predictor of people's actions in this situation, sets up two boxes containing things, and gives you a choice between taking **box A and B** and **box B** alone. Imagine [[Omega]], a perfectly honest being which is also known to be a historically very accurate predictor of people's actions in this situation, sets up two boxes containing things, and gives you a choice between taking **box A and B** and **box B** alone. At the time this is set to you, the contents of the boxes are fixed.
Box A contains $10000, an amount of money. It's transparent, so you can see that it contains this. Box B is opaque, but you are told (by Omega, who is perfectly honest) that it contains $1000000, a larger amount of money, **[[iff]]** it predicted that you would take **only** box B. Box A contains $10000, an amount of money. It's transparent, so you can see that it contains this. Box B is opaque, but you are told (by Omega, who is perfectly honest) that it contains $1000000, a larger amount of money, **[[iff]]** it predicted earlier that you would take **only** box B.
A CDT agent reasons that, regardless of what happened in the past, they will always get an extra $10000 by taking box A and B. Omega predicts this, so they receive a total of $10000.
An EDT agent reasons that their behaviour now is evidence about what the (unobserved) opaque box's contents are - conditional on them taking box A and B, the B very probably contains nothing, and conditional on them taking B only, B very probably contains $10000000. As such, they take box B only and receive $1000000.
=== Generalizations
The Transparent Newcomb's Paradox variant makes both boxes transparent.